TitlePage Title Prefixing In Form Is Not Transparent To User
Date23-Aug-2005 12:50:20 EEST
Version this site
SubmitterGregorHagedorn
Bug criticalityEnhancementRequest
Browser version
Bug statusClosedBug
PageProvider used
Servlet Containerthis site
Operating System
URL
Java version

1. When using forms such as SubmitNewIdea is seems that the page title can be prefixed with a predefined string.

Thus when I created IdeaSingleVersionForSavesBySameUserWithinHour, it actually became IdeaIdeaSingleVersionForSavesBySameUserWithinHour.

The prefixing is ok and I endorse it, the bug is that the prefixing is not transparent to the user. Thus the solution would be to add the prefixing information to the form that is seen by the user when submitting information in a form.


2. Also not that the prefixing occurs in the actual page title, but not in the page title displayed in the table at the top of the page. As a result, the header table for both bug and idea submissions contains a link that when clicked creates a new page, this time without the "Idea" or "Bug" prefix. I think this is highly confusing and should be fixed as well.

-- Gregor Hagedorn


This isn't exactly a bug - the form has just it defined so that it forces every page to have the same prefix. So it's by design. If our pages were named all differently, we would have a problem.

Besides, you are not supposed to write in the name as a wiki page - it's the title of the bug, not a WikiWord. In this case, the thing works nicely.

Perhaps a better explanation should suffice?

-- JanneJalkanen

For point 1 I know that this is the way it is designed, the bug is not the result, but that the result is unexpected by the user. The solution I try to propose is to make the result transparent to the user, e.g. by showing the prefix that is to be expected.

In regard to point 2, yes, a better explanation is necessary. The form currently explicitly says that "this becomes a WikiName". I would intuitively consider Wiki page "names" to be the "title" of a page, but that may be my error.

-- Gregor Hagedorn


I think the Bug report page now states it sufficiently clear, so I think the bug can be closed, feel free to re-open if you disagree.

--HarryMetske

Add new attachment

Only authorized users are allowed to upload new attachments.
« This page (revision-8) was last changed on 10-Mar-2007 14:37 by HarryMetske